Alyssa Caravella

Alyssa Caravella

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

Cell: 631-988-0819 Office: 631-583-8898

About Alyssa Caravella

A Long Island native, Alyssa O'Keefe has been a frequent Fire Island goer for many years. After graduating from SUNY New Paltz in 2013 with a bachelor’s degree in Marketing, Alyssa began building her career in marketing for sports & entertainment events.  After 5 years in the marketing industry, Alyssa decided to apply her marketing and promotion skills to the real estate industry.

Growing up around the construction industry, real estate had always been of interest to her.  Having spent many summer vacations on Fire Island, when the opportunity to join Fire Island Real Estate arose, Alyssa jumped at the chance to pursue her real estate career in such a beautiful and unique place. After specializing in rentals for two years, Alyssa has evolved into a strong sales agent.  With her extensive knowledge of the vacation rental market on Fire Island, Alyssa is an asset to those looking to purchase a rental investment property.  Alyssa is at your service to help you find the perfect home to produce top dollar on your investment or in purchasing your personal beach house retreat!



QUESTIONS? JUST ASK!
Showing 51 - 60 of 66 results| view:  results per page« first|...|3|4|5|6|7 »
  • Ocean Bay Park, NY
    $6,000 - $10,000
    5 Bedrooms 3 Full Baths
    Single Family For Rent ID# OBP-17r
    Nicely Updated 5 Bedroom 3 Bathroom 2 Story Home. Beautiful Hardwood Floors With 4 Spacious Bedrooms and 2 Full Bathrooms Downstairs. Open Concept Living/Dining/Kitchen Layout On Second Floor. A Secluded Master Ensuite Upstairs. Large Wrap Around Deck Perfect For Outdoor Entertaining. Pack Your Bags For The Ultimate Beach Retreat! <br> <br> Primary Suite: King <br> Bedroom 1: King + 1 Twin <br> Bedroom 2: Full + 2 Twins <br> Bedroom 3: 3 Twins <br> Bedroom 4: Twin Bunk Bed + 1 Twin (Total of 3 Twins)
  • Fair Harbor, NY 11706
    $5,950
    3 Bedrooms 1 Full Bath 1 Half Bath
    Single Family For Rent ID# FH-69r
    *New to Rental Market* <br> This three bedroom, one and a half bathroom "upside down" house is the perfect place to enjoy your summer vacation! Located in the laid back community of Fair Harbor, this home has all you need for fun in the sun. Covered front deck area with Adirondack chairs make for the perfect place to relax in the shade after a long day at the beach. Walk into the first level and you will find three bedrooms, one full bathroom, linen closet and laundry room. On the second level is an open concept kitchen, dining and living area with lots of natural light. Step out the sliders off of the kitchen, right to your grill with views of the Great South Bay! Take advantage of al fresco dining on the second story deck as you watch the sun set over the bay. Only a 3 minute walk down to the beach and 8 minute walk to the Fair Harbor ferry dock, Le Dock Restaurant, market, ice cream, pizza, playground & lifeguarded bay beach. Small dogs considered with additional pet fee. <br> <br> Available for weekly rent Monday - Sunday!
  • Ocean Bay Park, NY 11770
    $5,500
    3 Bedrooms 1 Full Bath 1 Half Bath
    Single Family For Rent ID# OBP-15r
    Just updated! Brand new wraparound deck with tons of space. Spend your summer vacation at this one level 3 bedroom, 1.5 bathroom home in the heart of laidback Ocean Bay Park! Spacious & comfortable living area with Smart TV perfect for lounging inside. Kitchen located off of living area with direct access to deck with grill and outdoor dining area. Two bedrooms and full bathroom with standup shower on north side of house. Situated off of the living room is third bedroom with private half bathroom and deck access. Back deck offers additional outdoor space for lounging in the sun plus private outdoor shower and shed with laundry & storage for beach chairs, umbrellas & bikes. Easy 4 minute walk down to the beach. Ocean Bay Park ferry & downtown area with restaurants, pizza & ice cream 5 minutes away. Take a 20 minute stroll or 10 minute bike ride over to Ocean Beach for more dining, shopping & entertainment. Pets considered with an additional fee. <br> <br> Bedroom Configuration: <br> Bedroom 1: Queen <br> Bedroom 2: Twin over Full Bunk <br> Bedroom 3: 2 Twins (Can be converted to 1 King) <br> <br> Available for weekly rent <br> July & August Weeks: $5,500 <br> June & September Weeks: $4,500 <br> Inquire within for short term availability and rates!
  • Ocean Beach, NY 11770
    $5,500
    3 Bedrooms 1 Full Bath 1 Half Bath
    Single Family For Rent ID# OB-541r
    Enjoy all Fire Island has to offer at this 3 bedroom, 1.5 bathroom home located only 3 houses back from the beach! Stay cool & comfortable with air conditioning in every bedroom and in the spacious living area. Head to town for dining, shopping, transportation & entertainment an easy 6 minute walk away! Beach chairs, beach umbrella, wagon & bikes provided. <br> Bedroom Configuration: <br> Bedroom 1: Queen Size <br> Bedroom 2: Full Size Bunk Bed <br> Bedroom 3: Full Size Bunk Bed
  • Ocean Beach, NY
    $5,500
    3 Bedrooms 1 Full Bath 1 Half Bath
    Single Family For Rent ID# OB-890r
    Charming 3 BR home on the east end of OB. Enjoy the luxury or being just a short walk to Seaview and to town. This home has all bedding, towels, beach chairs, bikes, wagon, BBQ and household basics provided. Nice private deck, pet friendly, and fabulous outdoor shower. <br>
  • Ocean Beach, NY
    $5,500
    4 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths
    Single Family For Rent ID# OB-612r
    This charming, renovated home is in a great location convenient to all. Huge yard and deck great for enjoying the sun and BBQ. 4 bedrooms. <BR>
  • Ocean Beach, NY
    $5,500
    3 Bedrooms 1 Full Bath 1 Half Bath
    Single Family For Rent ID# OB-502r
    This quaint single story house is located halfway between town and the beach in the Village of Ocean Beach. With 3 bedrooms & 1.5 baths, this home is a great place to spend your summer vacation. Stay cool and comfortable with air conditioners and ceiling fans in every room! Private back deck with spacious outdoor shower. This house has everything you need to enjoy life at the beach: beach pushcarts, beach chairs, beach umbrellas, beach towels, beach bags and even sand toys & a stroller umbrella for the little ones. Pack n play and high chair also available. Pet friendly with additional deposit. <br> <br> Bedrooms are as follows: <br> Primary Bedroom: Queen <br> Guest Bedroom 1: Full <br> Guest Bedroom 2: Full <br> Front sleeping porch: Twin Daybed with Twin Trundle <br> <br> May, June & September: $4,000/week <br> July & August: $5,000/week <br> <br> Inquire with Alyssa O'Keefe at alyssa@fisr.com or 631-988-0819 for availability!
  • Ocean Beach, NY
    $5,500
    5 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths
    Single Family For Rent ID# OB-957R
    This light & bright home has just been completely redone! Enjoy the brand new eat in kitchen with stainless steel appliances and breakfast bar. All new furnishings. Quiet location on Seaview/Ocean Beach border. 5 bedrooms, 2 full baths. Sunny rear deck. Available for weekly rental. <br> Bedroom breakdown is as follows: <br> Queen <br> 2 full beds <br> Queen <br> Queen <br> Pull out
  • Kismet, NY 11706
    $5,000
    2 Bedrooms 1 Full Bath 1 Half Bath
    Single Family For Rent ID# KIS-79r
    Enjoy all the comforts of home at this newly redone 2 bedroom, 1.5 bathroom home in Kismet! This home has been lovingly cared for for decades and was completely renovated in 2023. Stay cool with central air throughout! Fantastic location, an easy 3 minute walk from the ferry dock and only 4 minutes down to the beach! Small dogs considered. Kismet is small town on the western end of Fire Island, close to the famous Fire Island Lighthouse. There are 2 restaurants, a marina, market, pizza, ice cream, tennis courts and a playground, making it the perfect place to take advantage of the easygoing Fire Island lifestyle! <br> <br> Now booking for 2025! <br> <br> Bedroom 1: Queen <br> Bedroom 2: Full
  • Kismet, NY
    $4,945 - $8,795
    7 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths
    Single Family For Rent ID# KIS-125r
    Spacious 7 bedroom, 2 bathroom home ideally located in the center of Kismet! First floor with 4 bedrooms, bathroom, spacious living room with fireplace. Kitchen with easy access out to Trex decking with lounge chairs, 2 gas grills & outdoor shower. Upstairs are 3 additional bedrooms, den, bathroom, second story deck, laundry closet & wet bar with extra fridge. Comes equipped with beach chairs, beach umbrella & wagon. Only a 3 minute walk down to the beach & 3 minute walk to town for the market, dining, ferry & entertainment. The charming community of Kismet is easily accessible from Robert Moses Field 5 or via the Fire Island Ferry. <br> <br> Available: <br> Weekly: $8,795 <br> Midweek: $6,595 <br> Weekend: $4,945 <br> <br> Bedroom Configuration: <br> Bedroom 1: 3 Twins <br> Bedroom 2: Full & Twin <br> Bedroom 3: Full & Twin <br> Bedroom 4: Full & Twin <br> Bedroom 5: Full & Full <br> Bedroom 6: Full & Full <br> Bedroom 7: Full & Twin
Showing 51 - 60 of 66 results| view:  results per page« first|...|3|4|5|6|7 »