Loading...
Please wait
Fair Housing Notice
Login
or
|
Register
Sign Up
for additional options
Saved Properties
Saved Searches
My account
631-583-8898
Home
For Sale
For Rent
Commercial
Homeowners
Overview
List With Us
What is my Home Worth
Market Reports
Buyers
Overview
Our Approach
Frequently Asked Questions
Find an Agent
About Fire Island
Overview
About Fire Island
About Us
FIRE ISLAND COMMUNITIES
Fire Island Directory
Blog
Contact
Contact
Careers
Homes For Sale On Fire Island
show search panel
Select Price:
to
Beds:
Min Beds
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Max Beds
Baths:
Min Baths
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Max Baths
Sq. Ft.:
Min SqFt
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
1000
1100
1200
1300
1400
1500
1600
1700
1800
1900
2000
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
1000
1100
1200
1300
1400
1500
1600
1700
1800
1900
2000
Max SqFt
ML #
ML #
ML #
ML #
ML #
ML #
ML #
ML #
Search
Search
»
Property Criteria
Select Type:
All Property Types
Retail
Lots and Land
Business/Property
Commercial
Farm and Agriculture
Apartment
Condo
Single Family
Land
Office
Heavy Industrial
General
Multi Family
Vacant Lot
Warehouse
Light Industrial
Commercial Co-op
Coop
Condo
Business Only
Apt House
Free St Bldg
Indus Bldg
Misc
Shop Center
Small Stores
Store
Office Bldg
In City Lot
Department Store
Apartment
Commercial
Altele
Hotel / Boarding House
Studio Apartment
Recreation Area
penthouse
Factory Area
Office Building
Out of City Lot
Farm
House
Production Area
Industrial
Mixed Use
Investment
LuxuryFull Service
Elevator
Walk-up
Live Work
Legal Accessory Apartment
Apartment in House
Advantage (DHS)
NYCHA Section 8
HPD Section 8
HASA
2-4 Multi-Family
5+ Multi-Family
Farm Estate
Half Duplex
Mobile Home With Land
Mobile Home Without Land
Multiple Residence
Commercial
Residential
1 Family Detached
Townhouse
HOA
Projects
1 Family + Access Apt
2 Family
3 Family
4 Family
Multi-Unit
Mobile Home
Vacation
House
Project
Gas Stations
Gas Station
Homeowner Assoc
Efficiency
Duplex
Triplex
Special
Lease
Zoned Boat Dock
Zoned Residential
Fourplex
Income
Hotel
Timeshare
Unimproved Agri/Recreation/Mobile Home
Villa
Zoned Boat Dock
Zoned Residential
Apartment In Building
Ranch
Property
Seasonal
Restaurant
Building
Studio
Unimproved Land
Stock Cooperative
Dockominium
ResidentialIncome
ResidentialLease
House Rental
Foreclosure
Short Sale
Foreclosure
Short Sale
For Sale or For Lease:
Lease
Sale
School District:
Select
Bronx 11
Brooklyn 13
Brooklyn 14
Brooklyn 17
Brooklyn 18
Brooklyn 19
Brooklyn 22
Brooklyn 23
Brooklyn 32
City of New York
Elmont
Floral Park-Bellerose
Great Neck
Hewlett-Woodmere
Lawrence
Manhattan 6
Queens 24
Queens 25
Queens 26
Queens 27
Queens 28
Queens 29
Queens 30
Amityville
Babylon
Baldwin
Bay Shore
Bay Terrace
Bayport-Blue Point
Bayside H.S.
Bellerose
Bellmore
Bethpage
Brentwood
Bridgehampton
Broaward
Bronx
Canarsie
Cardozo
Carle Place
Center Moriches
Central Islip
Clinton Hill
Cold Spring Harbor
Commack
Comsewogue
Connetquot
Copiague
Dacula
Deer Park
District 25
E.N.Y.
East Hampton
East Islip
East Meadow
East Moriches
East Quogue
East Rockaway
East Williston
Eastport
Elmont
Elwood
Eny
Farmingdale
Fire Island
Floral Park
Floral Park-Bellerose
Floral Parkway
Forest Hills
Franklin Square
Freeport
Garden City
Glen Cove
Great Neck
Greenport
Half Hollow Hills
Hampton Bays
Harborfields
Hauppauge
Hempstead
Herricks
Hewlett-Woodmere
Hicksville
Howard Beach
Huntington
Island Park
Island Trees
Islip
Jamaica
Jamaica Hills
Jericho
Kings Park
Laurel
Laurelton
Lawrence
Levittown
Lindenhurst
Locust Valley
Long Beach
Longwood
Lynbrook
Malverne
Manhasset
Maspeth
Massapequa
Mattituck-Cutchogue
Merrick
Middle Country
Miller Place
Mineola
Montauk
Mount Sinai
N. Babylon
N. Bellmore
N. Merrick
N/A
New Hyde Park
North Hills
North Shore
Northport-East Northport
Nyc Public
Oceanside
Oxford
Oyster Bay-East Norwich
Ozone Pk
Patchogue-Medford
Plainedge
Plainview-Old Bethpage
Port Jefferson
Port Washington
Queens
Queensvillage
Quogue
Remsenberg-Speonk
Richmond Hill
Riverhead
Rockville Centre
Rocky Point
Roosevelt
Rosedale
Roslyn
S. Huntington
S.Ozone Park
Sachem
Sag Harbor
Sayville
Seaford
Shoreham-Wading River
Smithtown
South Country
South Manor
Southampton
Southold
Springfield
Springs
St. Albans
Staten Island
Syosset
Three Village
Tuckahoe
Uniondale
Valley Stream 13
Valley Stream 30
Valley Stream 24
W. Babylon
W. Hempstead
Wantagh
West Islip
Westbury
Westhampton Beach
Whitestone
William Floyd
Wyandanch
27
29
Property Style
Click to
Select a Property Style:
Please select
2 Family
2 Story
Antique/Hist
Apartment
Apt In Bldg
Apt In House
Barn
Building
Bungalow
Cape
Colonial
Comm/Ind
Condo
Contemporary
Co-Op
Co-Op
Cottage
Duplex
Estate
Exp Cape
Exp Ranch
Farm Ranch
Farmhouse
Garden Apt
Garden Building
Hi Ranch
Hi-Rise
Homeowner Assoc
House Rental
Houseboat
Land
Mediterranean
Mixed Use
Mobile Home
Modern
Nantucket
Other
Post Modern
Prewar
Raised Ranch
Ranch
Room Rental
Saltbox
Share Condo
Single Family
Splanch
Split
Split Ranch
Split Ranch
Store+Dwell
Store+Dwell
Studio
Timeshare
Townhouse
Traditional
Tudor
2 Family
Victorian
Click to
Remove a Property Style:
All Property Style
Type Sale
Business
Bus+Office
Inc Prop
Office
Prop+Bus
Property
Store
StoreFnt
Space Use
Audio
Auto
Bar
Beauty/Barber
Church
Deli
Distributor
Drug/Beauty
Fast Food
Florist/Nursery
Gas Station
Health Spa/Gym
Laund/Dry Clean
Liquor Store
Maintenance
Manufacturer
Marine
Misc
Motel/Hotel
Pizza
Recreation
Restaurant
Retail
Retail Food
Routes
Services
Stationary
Video
Wholesale
Rental Type
Select
August
AugustLabor
Flexible
July
July/August
June
Memorial-Labor
Month-Month
OffSeason
1 Year
2 Weeks
2 Year
Weekly
Winter
»
Features
Adult Community
Basement
Beach Rights
All Cats
Central Air
Cul De Sac
Docking Rights
All Dogs
Eat In Kitchen
Fireplace
Furnished
Garage
Gas Type
Select
Included
Not Included
Partial
Yes
No
Handicapped access
Heat
Heating Type
Select
Baseboard
Central Furnace
Electric Air Filter
Forced Air
Heat Pump
Hot Water
Hot Water Radiant Floor
Humidifier
Included
N/A
No
None
Not Included
Other
Partial
Pellet Stove
Radiant Ceiling
Radiant Floor
Radiator
Solar Active
Solar Active Passive
Solar Passive
Space Heater
Steam
Stove
SW Changeover
Unknown
Wall Unit
Yes
Zoned
New Construction
No Restrictions
No Cats
No Dogs
Parking Spaces
Min Parking
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Max Parking
Pets
Restricted Weight
Inground Pool
Private Entrance
Smoking
Waterfront
Waterview
Wood Floors
»
Display Tools
Include:
Photos
Virtual Tours
Open Houses
New to Market:
In Last Day
In Last Week
In Last Month
All
Sort by:
Price
Location
Date
Order:
Ascending
Descending
Search
36
properties match your search
;
36
with
Multiple photos
;
0
with
Virtual Tour
;
11
with
Videos
Save Search
Sort by
Price (High to Low)
Price (Low to High)
Price Reductions
Newest Listings
Open House Date
Number of Photos
Virtual Tours
Showing
11 - 20
of
36
results
| view:
10
15
20
50
100
results per page
«
1
|
2
|
3
|
4
»
27
26 Ontario St
Ocean Bay Park
,
NY 11770
$1,499,000
2
Bedrooms
2
Full Baths
Single Family
For Sale
ID#
OBP-26S
Situated only 300 feet from the beach, this modern home was just completely renovated. Designer details abound, from the stunning Terrazzo floors to the walnut ceilings and trim. Brand new kitchen with top of the line Thermador appliances, wine fridge, show stopping orange vent hood, and quartz countertops. The great room's massive glass sliding doors act as a dramatic architectural feature, and provide maximum connection between the living room and the deck & courtyard area. The oversized 75'X100' property provides the perfect setting to enjoy Fire Island living and includes a spacious deck, outdoor shower, and storage shed. Excellent location on the ocean block on a quiet street. Perfect for the discerning buyer seeking a modern home. Plenty of room to add a pool and expand the living space, if desired.
Presented By:
Fire Island Sales and Rentals
Save Listing
CONTACT
Email to a friend
Details
Call Today:
516-510-3207, or
Email:
Abigail Medvin Mago
Temporary Off Market
Upcoming Open House
View Location
18
Ocean Bay Park
,
NY 11770
$1,500,000
2
Bedrooms
1
Full Bath
Single Family
For Sale
ID#
OBP-17s
This charming 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom cottage is an ideal Fire Island retreat. Nestled on a spacious lot, the home offers a large deck perfect for outdoor entertaining, whether you're enjoying morning coffee or hosting a sunset gathering. The property provides the opportunity to keep the existing cozy cottage or build your custom dream home. With its prime location near Seaview, you’re close to local shops, dining, and ferry access, while still enjoying a peaceful atmosphere. Just steps from Fire Island's beautiful beaches, this is the perfect getaway or investment property for those looking to embrace coastal living. Don’t miss your chance to own a piece of paradise in a highly sought-after location!
Presented By:
Fire Island Sales and Rentals
Save Listing
CONTACT
Email to a friend
Details
Call Today:
516-510-3207, or
Email:
Abigail Medvin Mago
Call Today:
516-521-6842, or
Email:
Joan Woletsky
Temporary Off Market
Upcoming Open House
View Location
25
485 Bayberry Walk
Ocean Beach
,
NY 11770
$1,525,000
4
Bedrooms
2
Full Baths
Single Family
For Sale
ID#
OB-485s
485 Bayberry Walk, Ocean Beach <br></br> Move Right In! This charming Ocean Beach home for sale was completely renovated in 2021. Spacious and open great room, perfect for entertaining. Brand new kitchen with white cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, quartz countertops, breakfast bar and dining area. Hallway leads to three guest bedrooms, full bathroom and one primary suite with private bathroom. Ductless units in every bedroom and great room provide both AC & Heat. Outdoor entertaining is made easy with spacious deck, grill, and outdoor lounge set. Private outdoor shower on rear of wraparound deck, where you can also find extra storage closet & washer/dryer. Low flood insurance, only $1,903/year. Use this home for sale on Fire Island in Ocean Beach as an excellent rental investment or make it your home away from home! Conveniently close to ferry, shopping & dining. Only a 7 minute walk down to the beach! Schedule your showing with Alyssa O'Keefe today.
Presented By:
Fire Island Sales and Rentals
Save Listing
CONTACT
Email to a friend
Details
Call Today:
631-988-0819, 631-583-8898, or
Email:
Alyssa Caravella
Temporary Off Market
Upcoming Open House
View Location
34
125 Oak St
Kismet
,
NY 11706
$1,575,000
7
Bedrooms
2
Full Baths
Sq. Ft.
2064.00
:# SqFt
Single Family
For Sale
ID#
KIS-125s
Spacious 7 bedroom, 2 bathroom home ideally located in the center of Kismet! First floor with 4 bedrooms, bathroom, spacious living room with fireplace. Kitchen with easy access out to Trex decking with lounge chairs, 2 gas grills & outdoor shower. Upstairs are 3 additional bedrooms, den, bathroom, second story deck, laundry closet & wet bar with extra fridge. Property is high and dry! No Superstorm Sandy damage. Make this your family retreat at the beach or use as rental investment; excellent rental history! Ideally located, this home is only a 3 minute walk to either the beach into town for the trips to the market, dining, ferry & entertainment. The charming community of Kismet is easily accessible from Robert Moses Field 5 or via the Fire Island Ferry. Contact Alyssa to schedule your showing!
Presented By:
Fire Island Sales and Rentals
Save Listing
CONTACT
Email to a friend
Details
Call Today:
631-988-0819, 631-583-8898, or
Email:
Alyssa Caravella
Temporary Off Market
Upcoming Open House
View Location
30
Ocean Beach
,
NY 11770
$1,675,000
4
Bedrooms
2
Full Baths
Single Family
For Sale
ID#
OB-686s
Nestled in an idyllic setting, this stunning four-bedroom, two-bathroom home offers the perfect blend of coastal charm and urban convenience. Located just steps away from the serene shores of the ocean and situated in the heart of town, this residence provides unparalleled access to both natural beauty and vibrant city life. Imagine waking up to the gentle sound of waves and enjoying picturesque ocean views from your doorstep, all while being a stone’s throw from trendy shops, gourmet dining, and cultural attractions. This is more than just a house; it’s your dream home in an unbeatable location.
Presented By:
Fire Island Sales and Rentals
Save Listing
CONTACT
Email to a friend
Details
Call Today:
516-680-3705, 631-583-8898, or
Email:
Alan Medvin
Call Today:
516-521-6842, or
Email:
Joan Woletsky
Temporary Off Market
Upcoming Open House
View Location
39
22 Crescent Ave
Seaview
,
NY 11770
$1,699,000
4
Bedrooms
2
Full Baths
Single Family
For Sale
ID#
SV-22s
22 Crescent Ave., Seaview <br></br> Discover the perfect blend of classic charm and modern convenience in this beautifully maintained one-story home located in the heart of Seaview on Fire Island. Situated on an oversized 80 X 100 lot, this inviting home offers four spacious bedrooms and two newly renovated bathrooms. Step inside to find a light-filled dining room that blends natural beauty with seaside charm. Relax in the bright and cozy living room. The updated light & bright kitchen features contemporary finishes and great use of space. Enjoy relaxation and leisure in your private backyard, which includes a brand-new hot tub and lush, green grounds perfect for outdoor gatherings. Storage shed with laundry is perfect for stowing your beach chairs, umbrellas & bikes away from the elements. This Seaview home for sale allows you to enjoy all Seaview amenities, including access to the lifeguarded bay beach at the bayfront park, basketball courts, baseball field, and tennis courts. Ideally located less than a minute to the Seaview Ferry and Seaview Market, this home offers both tranquility and accessibility. Only a 5 minute walk to the beach! Take advantage of rental income at this home or use as your own escape. Don’t miss your chance to own this piece of paradise!
Presented By:
Fire Island Sales and Rentals
Save Listing
CONTACT
Email to a friend
Details
Call Today:
631-988-0819, 631-583-8898, or
Email:
Alyssa Caravella
Temporary Off Market
Upcoming Open House
View Location
26
5 Champlain St
Ocean Bay Park
,
NY 11770
$1,699,000
4
Bedrooms
4
Full Baths
Multi Family
For Sale
ID#
OBP-5
5 Champlain Street, Ocean Bay Park <br></br> Rare opportunity to own a 3 family home on Fire Island! Tons of upgrades, including all new roof, new roof deck, and Mini Split AC system throughout. Ideally located in the heart of Ocean Bay Park, this property is ideal for an investor or a savvy buyer looking to utilize one unit and rent out the other two. Why pay your mortgage when you can have tenants pay it for you, and still get to enjoy your property? The property has 3 separate apartments, each with its own private entrance and outdoor space. The front unit has 1 bedroom, 1 bathroom, and its own gated, private deck area. The middle unit has been tastefully updated, and has 1 bedroom , 1 full bathroom, and its own beautiful roof deck. The rear unit is the largest, featuring 2 bedrooms, 1 full bathroom, a renovated kitchen, spacious living area, and private deck area with laundry and a cabana bathroom and outdoor shower. Low taxes only $5,135! Affordable flood insurance, only $1,024/year. This home for sale in Ocean Bay Park is a unique and rare opportunity that is not to be missed!
Presented By:
Fire Island Sales and Rentals
Save Listing
CONTACT
Email to a friend
Details
Call Today:
516-510-3207, or
Email:
Abigail Medvin Mago
Temporary Off Market
Upcoming Open House
View Location
21
Ocean Beach
,
NY 11770
$1,800,000
6
Bedrooms
3
Full Baths
Single Family
For Sale
ID#
OB-961s
Make this spacious, six bedroom, three bathroom home your personal paradise at the beach! Situated on a 90 X 84 lot, this home has space for plenty of guests and entertaining. Fully winterized and ready for year-round use. Only 2 minutes to the bustling Village of Ocean Beach for transportation, dining, shopping & entertainment! Four minutes from the beach.
Presented By:
Fire Island Sales and Rentals
Save Listing
CONTACT
Email to a friend
Details
Call Today:
516-510-3207, or
Email:
Abigail Medvin Mago
Call Today:
516-521-6842, or
Email:
Joan Woletsky
Temporary Off Market
Upcoming Open House
View Location
29
19 Crescent Ave
Seaview
,
NY
$1,899,000
4
Bedrooms
2
Full Baths
1
Half Bath
Single Family
For Sale
ID#
sv-19s
19 Crescent Ave, Seaview <br><br> Enjoy this updated home located in the heart of Seaview! The home features 3 spacious bedrooms and 2 bathrooms in the main house as well as a private cottage with a queen sized bed and powder room. All bedrooms have access to exterior decks! The primary suite boasts a king size bed and lovely, updated ensuite. The second bedroom has a king size bed, perfect for a guest room & the third bedroom has a set of full over full bunkbeds. The well appointed and updated kitchen with Subzero Fridge has everything you need for your beach vacation. Stay cool with central air throughout the home. With a wrap around deck and screened in porch, there is plenty of space to relax, dine and soak in the sunshine. The wrap around deck also includes a hot tub providing the perfect retreat for relaxation and unwinding after a long day. Rinse off after a day at the beach in your private outdoor shower. This location provides easy access from both Seaview and Ocean Beach Ferries. Enjoy the amazing Seaview amenities - lifeguarded Bay & Ocean beaches, tennis courts, softball field and an impressive playground! This Seaview home for sale is a must-see! <br> Flood Insurance $3,525
Presented By:
Fire Island Sales and Rentals
Save Listing
CONTACT
Email to a friend
Details
Call Today:
516-521-6842, or
Email:
Joan Woletsky
Temporary Off Market
Upcoming Open House
View Location
35
112 Ocean Rd
Ocean Beach
,
NY 11770
$2,049,000
4
Bedrooms
2
Full Baths
Single Family
For Sale
ID#
OB-112s
112 Ocean Road, Ocean Beach <br></br> Built in 2012 and recently renovated this single story Ocean Beach home for sale with 4 BR + Loft, 2 BA has it all! This home is fully winterized and can be used year round. Beautifully appointed home on what many consider to be the prime block in Ocean Beach. Open kitchen with granite counters, center isle and seating for 6. Top-of-the-line stainless steel appliances including an oversized refrigerator, stainless steel vented hood, built-in draw microwave, white cabinetry & bar. Cathedral ceiling in the living room, dining room, and the kitchen. Sliders to the deck. Beautiful flooring throughout. Ensuite master bedroom with sliders to the large deck. Stay cool with Central Air and plantation style fans throughout. Only 10 houses from the beach on a 50' X 100' lot! Topping everything off is the pool on a west-facing deck for the enjoyment of the afternoon sun. Outdoor shower with changing room. Decks nearly 1,000 sq. st. All furnishings included. Don't miss out on viewing this beautiful home for sale in Ocean Beach!
Presented By:
Fire Island Sales and Rentals
Save Listing
CONTACT
Email to a friend
Details
Call Today:
516-521-6842, or
Email:
Joan Woletsky
Temporary Off Market
Upcoming Open House
View Location
Showing
11 - 20
of
36
results
| view:
10
15
20
50
100
results per page
«
1
|
2
|
3
|
4
»
Questions? Just Ask!
Please check I'm not a robot
Submit